Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Rabbi Michael Lerner, speaking about Cindy Sheehan's resignation from leadership of the US Anti-War movement:

People tell me that they believe most of my generation "sold out" after the 60s because they wanted the material advantages of the society. But in my experience the most talented, caring, sensitive and creative people I met in movement activities, particularly those who were willing to take the extra personal risks involved in becoming leadership and spokespeople for peace and justice, left the Left not because of a desire for material success, but because they felt abused by others on the Left and in the liberal world who, while agreeing with their ideas, nevertheless found ways to be inhumane, insensititve, and put-downish to others in their movement.

Rumors were spread that claimed that the most idealistic of these people were "really" just out for power, fame or ego-gratification of some sort, and that undercut the effectiveness of these leaders because others responded to them not by listening to their ideas, but by treating them as suspect because of "what they had heard."

Few of those who spread these negative stories really bothered to get to know the people about whom they gossiped, and few ever bothered to acknowledge how destructive this behavior was. But for those who were the objects of this kind of abuse, the feeling of being undercut by people who should have been allies caused personal pain and eventual despair that anything really could ever change. A few of us hung in and remain involved, in my case at least sustained by a personal spiritual practice, but for each 60s activist still involved, there are thousands who are not, who could not stand this way of being treated, and who, when they stick their nose into the dynamics of the present movements of the first decade of the 21st century, quickly discover the same kind of dynamics operating in the Left and in the liberal world.

2 comments:

RK said...

Yeah, I think there are several very hurtful practices that people don't take responsibility for because they can cover it up with "politics". It's disingenuous, not to mention dangerous.

Unknown said...

Hey Anne, I agree that the left can be a really unfriendly place (having been both the unfriendly and the unbefriended).

But...

I don't think that makes it ok to do nothing in the face of oppression, or worse, to take up a relatively privilaged place within an oppressive system.

(I'm not saying we don't all need to be much more thoughtful in our relationships with other activists and other people in general, I really do think we do - its really been driven home to me in the last few days that creating a supportive atmosphere (in particular for people in the left, which is so stressful) is just as important as running campaigns or talking about politics - I just think there's another side to it too.)